Had two recent contributions declined.
One with a 9-1 vote.

Planet of the Apes: The Legacy Collection
Universal Classic Monsters: The Essential Collection

Yes, over the past month or so I've seen many contributions go through that corrected the title to put the entire thing that appears on the cover in the title field for box sets containing several films.

So either all these contributions that moved or updated the title to include "Collection" names are wrong or the screening process is not following the rules.

For the Planet of the Apes set, I think it's rather clear that it's a collection of all Planet of the Apes films and that the 'The Legacy Collection' part is in regards to all the films in the set and thus part of the title.
It's not a 'Legacy Collection' of just the first Planet of the Apes film, as in different versions of that one films and thus 'The Legacy Collection' is a description of that one film and thus an Edition of that film

And the decline of the Universal Classic Monsters: The Essential Collection update is even dumber.
There is NO film at all called 'Universal Classic Monsters', thus it is impossible for an Edition to be used since that is not a film, but a box set.

Even the rules use a collection of films as an example to include it all in the title section.
Alien Quadrilogy.

It doesn't say to put only Alien in the title section and to put Quadrilogy in the Edition section. Because that is the title of the entire set/collection. Quadrilogy isn't an Edition of just one film (as in Alien).

And the word Edition does not appear at all in the Box Set rules section.
Surely if an Edition was to be entered in Box Set profiles it would have been put in the Box Set rules.

But it wasn't, so one could assume that what we see on the cover is to be entered completely in the Title section.
http://www.invelos.com/dvdpro/contributions/Rules.aspx?display=boxsets

Or the rules need to be updated, (like that'll ever happen anytime soon.)

Well enough of the rant, just wanted to mention these two titles so if anyone that owns them wants to update the title they can or if the don't, they won't.

Or if someone else wants to try to submit them again they can, but I give up on these two profiles.

FYI: If others want to chime in with their opinions they can, but this original post will be all I will say about this.

Quoting CubbyUps:

Quote:
...or the screening process is not following the rules.

This should come as no surprise to anyone who is paying attention.

---------------