I was going to submit changes to the Andromeda TV series DVDs but wanted feedback before I do as I am not sure if the current entries are correct by the word of the rules but not with the intent. I've noticed that what is actually the Volume number appears to be entered into the "Edition" field. I think this is due to in later seasons and later reprints of the cover art the volume information was listed as "Season #, Collection #". The rules do state "indicating special versions and collections". However, in reading the rules it appears to me when talking about collections means a named collection like "The Criterion Collection" (as noted in example) and not a collection of episodes. The original season one releases were all just "Andromeda" on the cover and on the spine had 1.1, 1.2, 1.3, 1.4 and 1.5 to indicate the season and volume.  The same was true for season two initially with the addition of the volume number under the series title as seen on the submitted cover scan:  Later Season 2 releases and reprints (not sure about season one) and all future seasons rather then the numbers (1.1, 1.2, 2.1, etc.) were printed as "Season X, Collection X" listed under "Andromeda" and on the spines as seen here:  My feeling is the use of the Edition field in the entries for all 5 seasons is wrong and they should be listed as for the first season: Title: Andromeda: 1.5 and Later Seasons: Title: Andromeda: Season 2, Collection 3 with the edition field left blank I wanted to get feedback before I submitted a change to all 25 volumes as if you follow the word of the Contribution Rules since the world collection is used they appear to be correct but my feeling is that the edition field was not intended to track volumes which is that the collection number actually is. Opinions? |