Short Circuit (Also general, I think)
at the opening credits we get:

Film Edited By
Frank Morris

At Time Index  01:31:33 (End Credits) we Get:
Film Editors JEFF JONES - DALLAS PUETT
Assistant Film Editor KEVIN STITT
Appretice Editor ANDY GREENBERG

so I add 2 film editors to the credits, one user says no: you cant"t:
Rules Crew:
refering to the notes section:

Quote:
Principal Editors listed when credited together

I  think the condition is met: film editors listed together in the end credits

or do we just take the one from the Opening credits?

Quoting Berak:

Quote:
I would say Frank Morris, Jeff Jones and Dallas Puett all get Film Editor credits.

Agreed; it seems pretty clear they all did the work.

Quoting tweeter:

Quote:
I'd've voted No if i owned the title.

The operative words are Principal and when credited together.  Jones & Puett meet neither criteria because because they are not credited together with the Principal editor, Morris.

If they weren't worthy to be co-credited with him they shouldn't be submitted.

Me too! The "Principal Editors listed when credited together" note is there for a reason. We can't just ignore it. Tweeter hits the nail on the head: Frank Morris gets a big credit in the opening credits, and Jeff Jones and Dallas Puett do not - they're buried somewhere deep down in the end credits. That doesn't make them the "principal editors listed when credited together" - they're not. IMHO, the rule is crystal clear, and this is exactly the situation it applies to. They should be left out.

Quoting Giga Wizard:

Quote:
there is a problem if you formulate it like that: All credits should come from the end credits.

Huh?! Says who? That would be quite problematic for the vast majority of the director, writer, producer, editor and production designer credits... 

applies only for cast; apparantly.

Quoting tweeter:

Quote:
I'd've voted No if i owned the title.

The operative words are Principal and when credited together.  Jones & Puett meet neither criteria because because they are not credited together with the Principal editor, Morris.

If they weren't worthy to be co-credited with him they shouldn't be submitted.

This seems to be the appropriate way to interpret the Rule.

Quoting hal9g:

Quote:
Quoting tweeter:

Quote:
I'd've voted No if i owned the title.

The operative words are Principal and when credited together.  Jones & Puett meet neither criteria because because they are not credited together with the Principal editor, Morris.

If they weren't worthy to be co-credited with him they shouldn't be submitted.

This seems to be the appropriate way to interpret the Rule.

I agree. "Principal" means "first or highest in rank, importance, value, etc.; chief; foremost. " That's the operative word. If two or more people share that rank, they would be credited together. In this example, however, Frank Morris is the principal.

To me principals are the same as supervisors. They all are the head of their department and therefore I enter both main and separate film editors as well as supervising crew and regular crew.