Well I am in favor of having one filed for a season box set and divide the cast and crew just seems to become so large when we enter child disc for for every disc. Now with entire series like Mash: Martinis & Medicine Collection that would have to be broken up by season I would imagine. Just giving my in put

Quoting Unicus69:

Quote:
Quoting Rifter:

Quote:
The new rules we worked up for 2.5 would have addressed this and eliminated most of the controversy.  I'm sad to see Ken hasn't included those changes in the intial rules for 3.0.

I am actually glad he didn't include those changes.  They are so outdated that it would have been a huge step backwards.  People were already used to the current rules so it was a good idea to let them continue with them.  As Ken said in another post, we can address any concerns and revise the rules as issues are identified.

I must have missed this one first time around.  How can you say the rules we did for 2.6 are a step backward?  They were definitively more up-to-date than the rules for 2.4 by any measure.  So maybe some of the stuff we expected didn't get into 3.0.  So what?  That still doesn't mean the entire effort was a waste.

In fact, many of the things we came up with in the way of fixes, we are STILL arguing about in 3.0. because some people just can't accept compromises.  The whole question of boxsets could be dealt with in one afternoon except for certain people who refuse to see that whether its TV or movie is immaterial.  But you all go right on ahead.  You're doin' a REAL swell job! 

Quoting whispering:

Quote:
Quoting hal9g:

Quote:
Apparently the fact that the Rules specifically define that boxset rules are only to be used for multi-year TV Sets, is irrelevant to you (and a few others).

Why would the box set area say on the credits "For additional information on handling of TV Series type releases see the TV series section." if we shouldnt add them? The rules say nothing about multi-year TV sets, at least i couldnt find any such info. Other then the credits part the rules say nothing about TV series in the Box Set section.

This has been quoted many times here, but here it is again.

From the Rules under TV Series:

"Note: In rare cases where multiple Complete TV Series are packaged together, the Box-set rules can be applied, treating each series like a single film - applying the above rules for it’s individual profile"

If the TV Series does not meet this "Rare" condition (not all that rare anymore, admittedly) where all Seasons have been bundled into a "COMPLETE SERIES" (in other words it is the entire show from beginning to end) then it should NOT be set up as a boxset, including boxset contents.

Quoting skipnet50:

Quote:
               

Skip

Roll your eyes all you want, Skip.

The plain meaning is quite clear and all of your contributions adding boxset contents are a violation of the Current Rules.  All of your votes against removing them are also a violation of the Current Rules.

Quoting Rifter:

Quote:
Quoting hal9g:

Quote:
Quoting skipnet50:

Quote:
               

Skip

Roll your eyes all you want, Skip.

The plain meaning is quite clear and all of your contributions adding boxset contents are a violation of the Current Rules.  All of your votes against removing them are also a violation of the Current Rules.

And of course you don't give a crap about what half the people want, do you, Hal?  It's your way or the highway, and nobody else is allowed to say otherwise.

You can say whatever you want.  But everybody should be following the Rules until they are changed!

It has nothing to do with "my way".  It has everything to do with what the Rules say.

And you are NOBODY, sir. keep your attacks to yourself. Why not go ahead and leave again, you know you will eventually, just like you have in the past.

Skip

Then stop with your harassment, ceaseless jabs and not so subtle attacks. Get it. THANK YOU.

Skip

You had no need to include me in your post, sir. Constant HARASSMENT.

Skip