I just looked at the listing on your collection site... The only thing I see that is wrong per the Rules would be the title... Rules says to only use the colon (:) for dividers... so it should be...

Friday Night Lights: Bonus Disc: Wal-Mart Exclusive

With Walmart Exclusive in the Edition field.

But I wouldn't think that would be enough to decline it. So I would think it is a combination of that and possibly the notes you used.

In your notes you want to write out not only what you are changing (or adding for new submissions) but where the info came from.

So I would think if you change the title to go per rules and expand on your notes you should be ok. If the cast info did not come from the credits removing them or documenting them with added uncredited box check would need to be done as well.

As for using sites for info... basically what we have is If it can come from the disc it has to... if it is for a field that you can not get from the DVD itself (SRP, Release Date and so on) you can use outside sources... but must have multiple sources to document the information.

Quoting tweeter:

Quote:
If this is a Bonus Disc why is there a cast/crew list at all?

Quote:
Some kind of 3rd party database list would be helpful, because, by that token, no sites can be used for reference.

3rd party databases can be used for reference (name variants, etc) but the source for the original cast/crew information needs to be the film/show credits.

Very true... I forgot about this rule...

Rules Quote:

Quote:
Do not list actors and crew who appear only in special features, or whose scenes were deleted from the main feature, even if they appear in special features.

So that could very possibly be the reason for the decline right there.