When it comes to images we all know that all monitors shows the images (at least slightly) different...so I think it is not to much to expect to almost always get some no votes on your images... as your images might look significantly better on your machine.. they may not on someone else's machine.

So I wonder if that don't come into effect here.. maybe on the no voter's machines there the images just aren't as good?

Problem there is that Gerri has publicly said there is times when she would keep a keep case scan over the slipcover scan... so since she has said that it falls back to what people prefer on their voting.

Here is Gerri's post... maybe it will shed some light on this topic as well?...

LINK

Other then that I can not give an opinion since I don't have this particular DVD.

Pete:

As Rory has indicated, the reflecvtive issue is totally irrelevant here. This particular slip is simply a high quality glossy image that is eminently scannable. So there is only one thing that applies, the RULE. Even Gerri's comment cannot override that.

Skip

LOL, the user in question, Pete, is in love with his own work and believes he is end all to scans, he like to say his are better and he got a couple of echoes. But the vast majority recognize that his scans which were quite nice did not follow the Rules and therefore have to be replaced.

Skip

Then add the DVD to your wish list to have a look, you don't have to vote on it, or keep it in your wish list.

024543-519652

I did and from I could see (viewing the two side by side) there's a slight improvement on the rear of Rory's but apart from that I see No reason for any No vote only that of violating the Rules, by stopping the slip from being accepted.

Steve

Edit: typo

I would suggest an addition to this part of the Rules cover Cover Scans.

If a DVD is packaged in a keep case, within a slipcase of some kind, scan the Cover Images from the outer slipcase. If, however, the Slipcase is reflective, and the inner cover art is identical, use the Keep Case art to scan, as it will give a better quality image.

The addition to this that I would suggest is:-

The only time a scan from the Keepcase would be accepted over an Outter Slip is When the Outter is Reflective or of a material that makes it hard to get a good scan.

Steve

Edit: typo, Skip this catching.

@snabo

Steve I kind of like your suggestion. It make the rule easier to follow for some.

Rory


@Skip

Skip I've known to "Fat Finger" at times myself.  

Rory

@Randy

Thanks for the vote of support.

@Berak,

I seem to have forgotten that one.    


Rory