I know the Box Set rules state to not include Subtitles, Audio & Disc Features in the main box set profile.

However I can't find anything regarding if the Video Data (Widescreen/Full Screen, Aspect Ratio, 2D or 3D, Color format or for 4K the Dynamic Range.

So, do we include those or for those profiles that include them, should they be deleted?

I wouldn't add them for a new parent profile, but I wouldn't delete them from an existing one.
Edit: That said, I'm not going to vote No when someone deletes them. I find them useless in a parent profile. I just wouldn't contribute deletions myself. Does that sound inconsistent? Maybe ...

Quoting CubbyUps:

Quote:
The audio doesn't belong because the Box Set profile is just a case/box.
So by that reasoning, neither does video.

This is the clincher for me as well. The rules state not to include audio data, and any line of reasoning that excludes the audio data, equally applies to the video data, so I've always left that out as well. A box set parent profile doesn't actually profile any video content - it's merely a profile for an empty container. That empty container doesn't have any video data, just like it doesn't have any audio data, cast, crew or even Disc ID's. So yeah, I consistently leave it out.

all these removing color is strictly against the publisshed rules.

From rules...

Quote:
Multiple —  Contains multiple programs which differ in their coloring methods (such as box sets or multi-film discs with a Colorized and Black & White version included).

In process of voting no to every one I see. .. As well as vote no to anything being removed that the rules don't say it has to be removed.

Quoting Addicted2DVD:

Quote:
all these removing color is strictly against the publisshed rules.

From rules...

Quote:
Multiple —  Contains multiple programs which differ in their coloring methods (such as box sets or multi-film discs with a Colorized and Black & White version included).

In process of voting no to every one I see. .. As well as vote no to anything being removed that the rules don't say it has to be removed.

All well and good except that comes from the DVD Specification rules.
A box isn't a DVD.

And I agree that the box shouldn't have Genres or Studios, as far as Studios go it should only have the Media Company.

As far as the running time, that's included in the Box Set rules. Why? I have no idea. For me that too doesn't really belong either.

I will leave up what I contributed and let it fly. If some get approved, fine. It some don't, fine.

To me it's logical that a box doesn't have any Video in it.

As far as the rules, well they haven't been updated since 2016. And between that date and today we've had the program updated. And yet many of the new features in the updated program aren't in the rules either, so one could argue that if it's not in the rules than any changes made to reflect the updated program is in itself forbidden.

Quoting greyghost:

Quote:
The reason box-sets have video info, you can't submit a new profile without supplying a video format.

True, but one can remove/change them later.

I had always thought that the data that was the same for each of the films was valid to leave in the parent profile. Example: 3 movies -

All 3 in Color - valid to leave in parent profile
All 3 Widescreen - valid to leave in parent profile (leave ratio unchecked, however, if different among the 3)
All 3 Comedy - valid to leave in parent profile
All 2D - valid to leave in parent profile

Quoting T!M:

Quote:
Quoting greyghost:

Quote:
The reason box-sets have video info, you can't submit a new profile without supplying a video format.

Sure you can! But only when that box set has child profiles - if it doesn't, then DVD Profiler doesn't know it's a box set, and it won't allow you to submit it as a bare-bones profile. But if the parent *does* have child profiles, then DVD Profiler *does* allow you to submit the parent bare-bones as it should be, without video info.

That in itself tells us how Invelos sees this. If it's not a box set, evidenced by no child profiles being attached, then video information is required. But if it's a box set, evidenced by the presence of child profiles, then that requirement is dropped immediately, and then you can submit the profile without video information. That's the answer to this whole question right there.

Didn't know that or never noticed that.

As you pointed out if Invelos allows a box set with child profiles attached without video data included in the parent then it's obvious that they(Invelos) doesn't require that video data to be included. Because if it was required you would get a pop up stating that you have to include video data before you even submit it.