Gerri sometimes makes mistakes too 

If your new contribution doesn't go through, try PM'ing her - that should get it sorted..

Quoting bentyman:

Quote:

where is runtime from ? cover states 102. And yes, cover says 102, but the actual RT is 96:40, therefore the change. I updated the notes and spesified that it was taken from the actual disc,

When I change Runtime I also state how I verified it, typically with PowerDVD.

Quoting Dvdjon:

Quote:
That was actually my no vote and I asked about this in this tread.

http://www.invelos.com/Forums.aspx?task=viewtopic&topicID=221850

(quote Dvdjon from the link:  "I believe the rules state a no vote in both cases, but do you guys check it out and submit the yes vote with confirmation that the runtime/crew is correct???
I believe the voting system is there so we wouldent have to do that tough.")

As you see everyone stated a no was warranted. therefeore I voted No because you did not state that you had it from disc or anything.

So you are voting Yes no mather what, only by the statement from the contributor?

There are people out there taking info from anywhere and puting on a standard phrase they know look good by screeners, we are the firewall for this missinformation, else the voting is not needed.

I have seen lots of NO woters with the statment of "where the info is from", if it is on the disc you should chech it anyway...  After a time one can start to trust some people and the check can be quicker, but to just trust the tekst along with the contribution is a little bit on the side by me..

Ole O.

No I do not vote yes no matter what thats why he got a no vote dude.

I cant check every single update by disc each time therefor I will vote no when there are no statement as to where this is from. If he had stated that the runtime checked by powerdvd or other place I could maybe checked it out as confirmation on a yes vote.

The notes there vere not in accord with rules and i asked on the forum and did as they said they would do.

I vote between 10 and 15 times a week(sometimes much more) and I do have better things to do than flipping disks into the dvd player. besides All contributors should remember that sometimes we are not home and have the possibility the verify by disk. Therefore we have to be able to trust the contributors statements that cast is from disc or runtime verifyed by powerdvd or something else.

I have never seen any contribution that has been willfully wrong, but I do have seen some wrong ones that has gotten a no vote from me just because they where unstaded as to where the changes got from or that they was dead wrong. The same day I voted no for this I also woted no to a cast update because the uploader did not state where he got them. I therefore assume they are cut and paste from Imdb. This uploader hovever pm'd me and told me that he had updated the notes to "gotten from end credits" and therefore i changed my vote to Yes.

In the last 30 days i have uploaded 106 contributions 103 of these has been released and 3 has ben withdrawn from me because I had misunderstood something in the rules.

Total no votes on these are 3 and only 1 on the 103 released ones. 2 are on the ones i withdrew.
the reason for this is that i state where i get the things from We cannot demand of all users who vote on these to flip out the disc and check everything. We have to trust the community and if a user do not state where the info is from he or she will get several no votes. and proparbly will get deleted even with only yes votes because kan and gerri has to trust us and they need us to state where we get the info from.

not for you skip, i started writing it before you had posted above me.      

There is no such thing as too much info...     

Keep on rockin'....

Hmm ok so you say mistrust everyone chec every single contribution by disk no matter what ?

sounds like sound advice.

I don't usually put the disc in to verify things, I just go by look, feel and who's submitting. I'm still newish so I don't know everyone, but feel there's a few I can trust just from their comments on mistakes I made in early contributions.
If I'm totally in the dark I won't go auto yes, I go neutral and let those who are (hopefully) sure to vote on it.

That reminds me, do neutral votes show up anywhere for contributions? I know my N vote does on pending that I've voted on, but I have been curious as to how many others voted N as well once or twice.
I imagine maybe the mods can see the full vote count but not the general poster, or are neutrals just thrown away?