I've come accross a list of undocumented Uncredited in The Devil Wears Prada UPC 5-039036-029643, locality UK,
pretty similar to the Uncredit list in IMDb.

Is it a close match of IMDB?
Like I said it's very similar, yet there are a couple of differences: a name in IMDb (Tim Krueger) is not present in DVDP, and there is another slight difference (Clacker / Clacker #1).
What do you reckon?




  DVDP database:
IMDb

    Ilona Alexandra = Celebrity on Red Carpet (uncredited) 
Ilona Alexandra ...  Celebrity on Red Carpet (uncredited)
   
    Andrea Bertola = Red Carpet Celebrity (uncredited)
Andrea Bertola ...  Red Carpet Celebrity (uncredited)


    Alexander Blaise = French Bellhop (uncredited) 
Alexander Blaise ...  French Bellhop (uncredited)

    Jaclynn Tiffany Brown (uncredited) 
Jaclynn Tiffany Brown ...  (uncredited)

    Carl Burrows = Businessman (uncredited) 
Carl Burrows ...  Businessman (uncredited)


    Molyneau DuBelle = Parisian Luncheon Guest (uncredited) 
Molyneau DuBelle ...  Parisian Luncheon Guest (uncredited)

    Guy A. Fortt = Security (uncredited) 
Guy A. Fortt ...  Security (uncredited)

    L. J. Ganser = Marty (uncredited) 
L.J. Ganser ...  Marty (uncredited)

    Alexie Gilmore = Clacker #1 (uncredited) 
Alexie Gilmore ...  Clacker (uncredited)


    Scott Hatfield = New York Mirror Reporter (uncredited) 
Scott Hatfield ...  New York Mirror Reporter (uncredited)

Tim Krueger ...  Fund Raiser (uncredited)
(no match in DVDP)

    Nina Lisandrello = Super Clacker (uncredited) 
Nina Lisandrello ...  Super Clacker (uncredited)


    Zev McAllister = Runway Editor (uncredited) 
Zev McAllister ...  Runway Editor (uncredited)


    Denis McKeown = Guest - Black & white Ball (uncredited) 
Denis McKeown ...  Guest - Black-and-white Ball (uncredited)

    Justin Restivo = French Waiter (uncredited) 
Justin Restivo ...  French Waiter (uncredited)


    Sage Salzer (uncredited) 
Sage Salzer ...  (uncredited)

    Emily Sandberg = Superclacker (uncredited) 
Emily Sandberg ...  Superclacker (uncredited)

    Robert Stio = Photographer (uncredited) 
Robert Stio ...  Photographer (uncredited)

    Taylor Treadwell = New Assistant (uncredited) 
Taylor Treadwell ...  New Assistant (uncredited)

Quoting skipnet50:

Quote:
(...) The data was never properly documented and slipped past the screeners. (...)

While this may be true, it is not the answer to the question. To remove uncredited credits you have to either document that it is wrong or you have to document that it is a close match to IMDb. Therfore the question is if this match to IMDb is close enough to remove the data without further documentation. In this case I would say yes because the role names are very close almost identical even where they are not the obvious name to be choosen.

The other question is...is the data correct? If it's correct then it doesn't matter if it matches IMDB. So if you can't verify that there is something incorrrect about the data, I would leave it alone.

Quoting EnryWiki:

Quote:
I know the search tool is not very powerful, but you can google "close match" site:invelos.com, and you'll find this clarification by Ken, posted on September 21

Mmm, seems to me you already had your answer. So why did you ask?

I think it's a close enough match to warrant removal, but it would be very nice of you if you did a quick search and double-checked that you definitely can't verify their inclusion first.
Removing those you can't verify and adding the documentation for those you can would be a great help to the database.

Quoting northbloke:

Quote:
I think it's a close enough match to warrant removal, but it would be very nice of you if you did a quick search and double-checked that you definitely can't verify their inclusion first.
Removing those you can't verify and adding the documentation for those you can would be a great help to the database.

That's what I'll do. Totally agree. 

Quoting Martin_Zuidervliet:

Quote:
Uncredited data should never be removed unless it's 100% identical to a third party database or the data remover can prove the uncredited cast do not exist.

Which is, of course, not how the rules say it can be done.

It's amazing, John, how these people see things, they will allow Rules to be blatantly broken, they are willing to impose their will on everyone to suit their convenience, and they are willing allow data to remain that was clearly illegal to begin with and undocumented. not to mention how little they comprehend of Db design. Their logic while understandable is completely illogical.

Skip