With all the DVD's that we collect and watch, I think it would be a good idea if there was a place to comment on the films themselves. I usually buy my DVD's at Walmart in the 5 dollar bin or used at Block Buster Video or Newbury Comics. I'll buy films that are ones that I have not seen in the theatre for one reason or another and when I can pick it up for under 5.00 I will. I have to say as of recent I have had a bad run of awful films. Reno 911 Miami and Shaggy Dog with Tim Allan as of recent. I think a forum to get individual opinions of the movies themselves would be beneficial and perhaps a rating system to add to the profile in DVD profiler would add benefit to the Profiler software.

I did not know that was there. I was just checking it out and saw the DVD Review and Film Review. When you click on comments though I got an access violation in 008a593a of dvdpro.exe. Where do you comment on the film to give your opinions and where can you read what others have written.

The access violation normally appears when you click on Comment but there is no review you can comment (text field empty, nobody wrote a review yet) 
To write your own review, use Contribute Review from the Online menu (or the star with hand icon in the tool bar)

That's useful info 8Ball. If I hear it blows chunks for the majority of reviews I would be least likely to buy. In going through my collection I only found one review so far after reviewing 100 profiles. This is clearly a feature that is not used. If there were an icon that could be highlighted to see reviews when available that would be cool. Being the film lovers we are, I would like to see more reviewing of films we own.

And I for one would not be opposed to 8Balls film reviews. Reno 911 Miami and Shaggy Dog blew CHUNKS.

The review feature would be much more useful if there was an indicator in the general info section (and as option for HTML windows) that a text review is available for a profile. I have just clicked on the review button of about 100 profiles just to learn that no review is available.

Leos Janacek said and I paraphrase no knowing Czech " Nobody builds statiues to critics."

I have done a couple reviews for DVDProfiler... but not many. I Know I did the first couple of seasons of Alias... other then that I am not sure.

I do some (amateurish)  reviews for different forums and email lists... I will have to try to add my over-all thoughts to DVD Profiler as well. After all... every little bit helps I guess. 

Quoting wtmac:

Quote:
So I guess the game here is to collect shiny discs, Figure out how to store the shiny discs, argue with others about the common names and rules in how to profile the shiny discs, but not to watch the shiny discs or review the content of the shiny discs as it would take away from all of the above.

No. Watch the shiny discs, review the shiny discs. Whether I choose to read anyone's review is my business. I may; I may not.

I choose not to write a review, because I suspect no one will read beyond the first paragraph or three, and by then, I'm moving away from my introductory remarks and heading into the meat of the essay. Ken's storage would run out of room before anyone with amazing willpower could reach any of my conclusions.

My BA is in English, with a concentration in Film Criticism, and a minor in Film, Radio, and Television Production. I tend(ed), as I wrote, to be awesomely verbose when discussing media in critical fashion. One professor wrote on an essay I submitted, "I asked for three pages, not Eisenstein's The Film Sense."